top of page
Search

Review – Mycroft Holmes: Fogbank

Writer: T Rick Jones
T Rick Jones
3 days ago
3 min read

Several years after the Autumn of Terror, when the Ripper murders plagued the East End of London, and more than a year after the supposed death of Sherlock Holmes, a new series of murders rocks Whitechapel – murders that echo those that baffled the police nearly five years earlier. Is there a copycat serial killer on the loose, or is Jack back? In JS Barnes’s Mycroft Holmes: Fogbank, Mycroft becomes embroiled in the new, yet hauntingly reminiscent, killings.


I interviewed Barnes last year in Sherlock Holmes Magazine, issue 22, about his full-cast Holmesian audio series produced by Big Finish Productions. Now, commissioned by Amazon-owned Audible Studios, he’s tackling a series of audio novels focusing on Sherlock’s smarter elder brother, set during the three dark years when London was bereft of the consulting detective. It’s no spoiler to say that the end of the novel makes it clear that Barnes plans for it to be only the first in a succession of narratives following the Holmes who, at times, “is the British government,” according to Sherlock.



Presented as a list, the elements that go into the tale seem almost ordinary: Victorian London; Mycroft Holmes; Jack the Ripper; a secret society – all subjects that have been well explored by sundry writers over the years. In Barnes’s hands, however, those elements are deftly blended in a fresh, interesting and often unexpected way.


The audiobook runs for nearly nine hours, and I listened to it on my roughly 35-minute commute to and from my job at a theatre over the course of about a week. From the first line, I was hooked, and I looked forward to getting back into my car each day to see where the tale would take me next. Barnes’s prose is easily digestible, and his colourful cast of characters, both canonical and original, are well defined.


It doesn’t hurt that the book is read by Olivier Award-winning actor Rory Kinnear (No Time to Die [2021], The Diplomat [2023–present]), whose rich, smooth baritone is easy on the ears, and whose reading of the story is pitch-perfect for the subject matter.


In the tale, Mycroft shows an uncharacteristic amount of energy. Far from the Nero Wolfe-esque armchair detective one might expect him to be, he is forced to visit many locations throughout the novel. Barnes doesn’t neglect to acknowledge this, even at one point suggesting that the corpulent Holmes has gained additional weight, making his travels around London even more challenging. His brainpower is as effective as ever, however, and he capably investigates the mysterious affair with the help of Doctor Watson and his new servant, the whimsically named Miss Liberty Bliss.


Fogbank is told in the third person, and the idea of an omniscient narrator is not at all uncommon: an all-seeing, all-knowing companion to the reader (or listener, in this case) who describes a book’s settings and characters’ thoughts and actions to the audience. Here, again, Barnes’s writing puts a unique spin on the heterodiegetic nature of the narrative. The narrator in this case isn’t just looking in on the events of the story, but has some knowledge of both the future and the past. Although he remains impartial in the telling, one gets the distinct impression that he has definite opinions about many of the events and characters in the book. Barnes even throws the occasional “I” statement into the account, making the listener feel that they are being told the tale by an actual person sitting with them, rather than an impersonal, disembodied voice. If the book as a whole is a recipe for tender, juicy chicken, then Barnes’s subtle narrative touches are the curry sauce that elevates the dish from delicious to scrumptious.


Listen, audiobooks aren’t for everyone. But if you’re a Sherlockian who’s never tried one and is on the fence about them, this might be a good place to start. And if you’re an aficionado of such things, you shouldn’t hesitate to download it. Barnes’s book is filled with surprising twists, and you’ll gladly follow his characters wherever they may lead; boredom is never a factor.


You can get Mycroft Holmes: Fogbank by JS Barnes from the Audible website or via the app.


 
 
bottom of page